Gas vs. Electric Boiler Installations

Are you considering a new boiler installation? If so, you might be weighing the differences between a gas boiler and an electric boiler. Choosing the right boiler for your home is a crucial decision that affects efficiency, running costs, environmental impact, and overall comfort.

In this guide, we’ll explore the key differences between gas and electric boiler installations, covering installation requirements, costs, efficiency, environmental impact, and maintenance.

Table of Contents

Installation Requirements

Gas Boiler Installation

Installing a gas boiler isn’t just about picking a unit and plugging it in—it’s a highly regulated process that ensures safety and efficiency. Here’s what’s involved:

  • Certified Expertise Required: A gas boiler must be installed by a Gas Safe registered engineer—this is a legal requirement, not just a suggestion! This ensures that your boiler is installed to safety standards, reducing the risk of gas leaks and carbon monoxide poisoning.
  • Gas Line Connection: If your home already has a gas line, you’re in luck! But if not, additional steps (and costs) will be required to bring gas into the property. This might involve running new pipes from the mains supply, which can add complexity and expense.
  • Venting & Flue Installation: Unlike electric boilers, gas boilers generate exhaust gases that need to be safely expelled. This means you’ll need a flue system, either through an external wall or chimney, to prevent dangerous gases from lingering inside your home.
  • System Integration: Gas boilers are designed to work with central heating systems, so proper integration is key. This means connecting it to radiators, underfloor heating, or hot water cylinders, depending on your home setup.
Electric Boiler Installation

If you’re looking for an easier, more flexible installation process, an electric boiler might be the way to go. Here’s why:

  • Who Can Install It?: Unlike gas boilers, which require a specialist, electric boilers can be installed by a licensed electrician, an HVAC technician with electrical certification, or a boiler specialist. This opens up more options for getting the job done.
  • No Gas? No Problem!: Since electric boilers don’t rely on gas, there’s no need for a gas line. This is a great option for homes that aren’t connected to the gas grid or homeowners who want to phase out fossil fuels.
  • Check Your Electrical Supply: Electric boilers require a significant power supply, so it’s essential to ensure that your property’s electrical system can handle the boiler’s requirements. In some cases, an upgrade to the electrical panel may be necessary, especially in older homes.
  • No Venting Required: Since electric boilers don’t produce combustion gases, you won’t need to install a flue or ventilation system. This makes them easier to place anywhere in your home, whether it’s a kitchen cupboard or a utility room.

Stay Warm All Year with a Boiler You Can Trust

Installed By Qualified Heating Engineer

1. Site Survey

Before installation begins, a professional will conduct a site survey to assess the best location for the boiler. This involves checking:

  • For gas boilers: The proximity to an existing gas supply, whether a new gas line is required, and the best placement for the flue to ensure proper ventilation.
  • For electric boilers: Whether your electrical system can handle the additional load or if an upgrade to your electrical panel is needed to accommodate the increased energy demand.
  • General considerations: The best location for accessibility, ease of future maintenance, and proper integration with your home’s heating system. Factors such as available space, water pipe positioning, and insulation efficiency will also be reviewed.

2. Preparation

Once the assessment is complete, any necessary modifications will be made to ensure a seamless installation. This can include:

  • Installing or upgrading a gas line if your property does not already have one. This may involve digging trenches, installing new pipework, or modifying existing gas infrastructure.
  • Enhancing the electrical infrastructure if an electric boiler requires additional power capacity. This could mean upgrading your electrical panel, installing new circuits, or ensuring the boiler has a dedicated power supply to prevent overloading your home’s electrical system.
  • Preparing the water supply and heating system to ensure proper integration with the new boiler. This includes checking and flushing pipework, installing additional insulation if necessary, and confirming that existing radiators and hot water cylinders are compatible with the new system.
  • Structural adjustments: In some cases, minor modifications may be needed to walls, cabinets, or pipe routing to accommodate the new boiler unit, especially for properties transitioning from gas to electric.

3. Boiler Installation

With preparations complete, the actual installation begins:

  • The boiler unit is securely mounted in its designated location, ensuring stability and accessibility for future maintenance.
  • For gas boilers, the gas supply is connected, and the flue is installed to properly expel exhaust gases, ensuring compliance with safety regulations.
  • For electric boilers, wiring is completed, and the unit is connected to the home’s electrical system. Safety measures, including circuit protection and grounding, are checked to ensure compliance with electrical codes.
  • Pipework is integrated, connecting the boiler to the home’s radiators, underfloor heating, or hot water supply. Proper insulation of pipework is ensured to minimize heat loss and enhance efficiency.
  • The boiler is securely fastened, and all necessary connections are checked before proceeding to the next stage.

4. System Testing & Commissioning

Before switching everything on, a series of tests are conducted to verify the system is safe and operational:

  • Safety checks: Engineers will check for gas leaks (for gas boilers) or electrical faults (for electric boilers), ensuring all connections are secure and hazard-free.
  • Pressure testing: The system is pressurized and monitored for leaks or fluctuations that could indicate potential faults.
  • Performance verification: The heating output and efficiency of the system are evaluated to ensure optimal functionality. Engineers check that all radiators and hot water outputs receive an even and consistent heat supply.
  • Flue gas analysis (for gas boilers): The emissions from the flue are measured to ensure they meet legal and safety standards.
  • User instructions: Homeowners are given a full walkthrough of their new boiler, including operating guidance, troubleshooting tips, and maintenance schedules to ensure longevity and performance.

Stay Warm All Year with a Boiler You Can Trust

Installed By Qualified Heating Engineer

Cost Comparison

Gas Boiler

Higher initial installation costs due to gas line setup(if property isn’t already set up with gas), ventilation, and complex installation requirements.

Lower running costs as gas is generally cheaper than electricity in many areas.

Electric Boiler

Lower initial installation costs as there is no need for a gas supply or venting.

Higher running costs since electricity is usually more expensive per unit than gas.

Efficiency Differences

Gas Boilers: Typically more efficient in larger homes due to their ability to generate heat quickly and at a lower energy cost.

Electric Boilers: More efficient for smaller homes or properties where electricity is the only available energy source. They have nearly 100% efficiency as all the electricity used is converted into heat without any waste.

Environmental Impact

Gas Boiler

CO2 Emissions: Produces greenhouse gases, contributing to environmental pollution.

Fossil Fuel Dependency: Gas extraction and combustion have negative environmental impacts.

Modern Condensing Gas Boilers: Can be more efficient and reduce emissions compared to older models.

Electric Boiler

Cleaner Alternative: If powered by renewable energy, electric boilers produce zero operational emissions.

Grid Dependency: The environmental impact depends on how electricity is generated in your area (fossil fuels vs. renewables).

Maintenance Requirements

Gas Boiler

Requires regular maintenance and an annual service to ensure efficiency and safety.

Safety checks are crucial to prevent gas leaks and carbon monoxide poisoning.

Electric Boiler

Minimal maintenance required as there are fewer moving parts.

No risk of gas leaks or carbon monoxide emissions, making them inherently safer.

Pros and Cons

Gas Boiler `pros

✅ Highly efficient, especially for larger homes

 ✅ Lower running costs due to cheaper gas prices 

✅ Can produce a high level of heat output

Gas Boiler Cons

❌ Higher installation costs 

❌ Requires proper ventilation and regular maintenance 

❌ Potential safety risks such as gas leaks and carbon monoxide emissions

Electric Boiler Pros

✅ Simpler and cheaper installation 

✅ No emissions when powered by renewable energy 

✅ Safer as there are no gas leaks or combustion risks

✅ Compact and ideal for homes without gas access

Electric Boiler Cons

❌ Higher running costs due to electricity prices 

❌ May not be suitable for larger properties with high heating demands

Conclusion

The choice between a gas boiler and an electric boiler depends on various factors such as property size, heating requirements, cost considerations, and environmental impact preferences.

  • Gas boilers are ideal for larger homes with high heating demands and offer lower long-term running costs.
  • Electric boilers are perfect for homes without a gas supply, offering safety, easy installation, and the potential for zero emissions when using renewable energy.

When deciding on a boiler, consider your budget, long-term energy costs, and environmental impact goals. If in doubt, consult a professional who can assess your home’s requirements and recommend the best option for you.

More Tips & Advice

Boiler installation

Boiler Installation Table of Contents Baxi, Worcester, Vaillant and much more When your heating system starts showing signs of age

Read More
Finance Type Interest Bearing
Purchase Price £0.00
Deposit
Select Deposit
Terms (length)
Select Loan Term

Amout of credit

£0.00

Monthly

£0.00

Total payable

£0.00

Interest (fixed)

£0.00

APR

-

GET IN TOUCH